(Kyiv) Excessive, confusing, and arbitrary restrictions on movement, imposed in parts of eastern Ukraine by Russia-backed armed groups in response to the Covid-19 pandemic, fail to properly accommodate humanitarian imperatives and put an undue burden on civilians, Human Rights Watch said today. In many cases these restrictions block access to health care, basic income needed to survive, and essential family visits among people who have grown increasingly impoverished and socially vulnerable due to the protracted armed conflict in eastern Ukraine.
Restrictions differ in the two nongovernment-controlled areas in Luhanska and Donetska regions and are discussed in more detail below.
Armed groups in the self-proclaimed Donetsk Peoples Republic (DNR) ban people with local permanent residency from leaving and allow entry for only those pre-approved on humanitarian grounds. Pre-approval is complicated and can take weeks. Local permanent residents can apply on a case-by-case basis for exceptions to leave on limited humanitarian grounds, but why and how these exceptions are granted is unclear and at times appears arbitrary. Additionally, people who leave DNR must promise in writing not to return until the pandemic is over.
Movement restrictions can be a legitimate tool to protect public health, but they shouldnt keep people from getting medical treatment or their pensions, said Yulia Gorbunova, senior Europe and Central Asia researcher at Human Rights Watch. The self-proclaimed republics in eastern Ukraine are preventing people from essential travel instead of ensuring appropriate exemptions are available and work in practice.
Human Rights Watch interviewed 16 people who live in Donetska and Luhanska regions who reported either difficulties obtaining permission to cross the line of contact or said that the regulations were so unclear that they didnt even attempt to cross. Several people said that they applied for special permission to leave the nongovernment-controlled area of the Donetska region but never received a response. One person was approved on humanitarian grounds. Ten people said that they had no choice but to travel through Russia to get to government-controlled areas of Ukraine. One person reported verbal and physical abuse and threats at a crossing point in the nongovernment-controlled area in the Luhanska region.
Entry-exit crossing points for civilians to cross the 427-kilometer line of contact, which separates nongovernment-controlled areas of eastern Ukraine from government-controlled areas, were shut down in March 2020 in response to the Covid-19 pandemic. Before the shutdown, there were over a million crossings each month, with people traveling mainly to get their pensions, see family, or to access health care. The Ukrainian government and armed groups started easing restrictions in May but reimposed them in October in response to an increase in Covid-19 cases.
The Stanytsia Luhanska crossing point, the only one currently operating in Luhanska region, was shut down on October 15 and reopened in early November. When it closed suddenly, about 80 people were stranded on the government-controlled side until the end of October, according to humanitarian groups. Many were older people returning after collecting their pensions or getting medical treatment.
As of November 13, only one entry-exit checkpoint in Donetska region allows crossings for civilians twice a week, on Mondays and Fridays, and the crossing point in Luhanska region is open daily. Two additional checkpoints for Luhanska region, in Zolote and Schastia, opened on November 10 but only on the government-controlled side.
The harsh restrictions, coupled with unclarity as to how exemptions are sought and granted, have had a particularly punitive impact on people seeking to reunite with family, act as caregivers for family members, access their pensions and social benefits, or access urgently needed health care.
For example, a 61-year-old man from Donetsk was diagnosed in mid-October with pneumonia. The doctor who examined him warned his family that his condition was critical, and he should urgently start a medication that was not available in DNR. Because of the restrictions imposed by the de facto authorities, the family could not travel to the nearest government-controlled town to buy the medication. Instead, they had to pay someone to deliver medicines from Russia, which doubled the cost and more than doubled the amount of time it took for him to receive the medication.
To avoid the challenging and confusing travel restrictions, people who need to travel from nongovernment-controlled to government-controlled areas of Ukraine increasingly opt to travel through Russia. However, the journey is long and prohibitively expensive to some, costing between 2,000 to 4,000 hryvnas (approximately US$70-140). Such crossings violate Ukrainian law and are punishable by a fine.
Although freedom of movement is not absolute and can be restricted, including in the interest of public health, all restrictions should be necessary and proportionate. The authorities and entities in charge of regulating crossing between government-controlled and nongovernment-controlled territories should ensure that restrictions dont exceed public health needs, taking into account other less intrusive measures to help prevent the spread of the virus. Those in charge also should make sure restrictions, and their exceptions, are clear and accessible and are not applied arbitrarily. The authorities and entities in charge should not impose strict blanket restrictions that can have a disproportionate impact on vulnerable populations and fail to take into consideration individual circumstances and rights. Instead, they should ensure there is a process for exceptions on humanitarian grounds that gives due weight to the rights of the individual seeking to cross and provides clarity and legal certainty.
All actors should ensure that people with humanitarian needs are able to cross the line of contact and that criteria and procedures for crossing are transparent, clear, and consistent. DNR de facto authorities should immediately drop excessive restrictions, including the rule banning people with local residence permits from leaving the territory.
Civilians in eastern Ukraine have been through a lot in the last six years, and do not need avoidable extra hardship, Gorbunova said. All parties need to ensure that their measures to protect public health during the pandemic are not so rigid or arbitrary that they violate peoples rights to health or their livelihood.
For details on restrictions and accounts from those adversely affected, please see below.
Travel Restrictions in the Self-Proclaimed Donetsk Peoples Republic (DNR)
The DNR prohibits people without permanent residency in government-controlled areas from leaving unless they apply for and are granted an exemption for a reason such as medical treatment or family reunification. In practice however, approvals are extremely rare, a senior staff member of a humanitarian group operating in Donetsk told Human Rights Watch in a phone interview.
People who wish to enter DNR and can show they have permanent residency there are allowed to do so only if they have been pre-approved on humanitarian grounds. On arrival, there is an option of taking an express Covid-19 test at the checkpoint. However, even if the test is negative everyone arriving is required to complete a two-week self-isolation period. One man who arrived in DNR on October 16 told Human Rights Watch that tests cost 1,750 rubles (approximately $21), which he could not afford, and which is prohibitive for many people. Those who do not take the test or test positive are quarantined in a medical facility for two weeks.
Most people seeking to travel to or from nongovernment-controlled areas of Donetska region said that they did not know how to get pre-approval to cross or whom to ask for assistance. Experts with Right to Protection, a Ukrainian human rights group that works with the internally displaced and monitors conditions on crossing points on the government-controlled side, told Human Rights Watch that people frequently dont know whether they have been included in pre-approved lists until they get to a crossing point.
One woman from Donetsk summed it up:
It is so complicated that it can drive you crazy. If you have a local [residence permit], you cant leave. If you have the permit on the other side, you can leave but you cant come back. My parents are both old and need medicine that is not available here, not to mention they havent been getting their pensions since February. And what are we supposed to do?
Travel Restrictions in the Self-Proclaimed Luhansk Peoples Republic (LNR)
In Luhanska region, people can cross to government-controlled areas without restrictions, but only those who have permanent residency in LNR are allowed to return to, or enter, the nongovernment-controlled area. People crossing into LNR must self-isolate for two weeks. In October, armed groups in control of the area introduced a new rule limiting crossings for people with permanent residence to once a month, but later adjusted it to allow more crossings if relevant health entities grant permission.
Movement between the two nongovernment-controlled areas has also been restricted, with the exception of people who are traveling to their place of permanent residence.
Accounts of Those Affected by the DNR Restrictions
Elena, HorlivkaIn September, Elena, who is 82, needed to travel to government-controlled territory for her daughter-in-laws funeral. Because of the travel restrictions, she had to travel through Russia, an arduous journey that took more than 24 hours and cost 1,300 hryvnas (approximately $45). We had no idea how it works, nobody really knows, her son said in the phone interview when asked if she had applied for an exemption. Someone told her that she should go to the military commander and beg for permission to travel but that it could take weeks.
Why does she have to go through such difficulties just to see family and attend a family funeral? he said.
At the Russia-Ukraine border, Ukrainian border guards fined Elena, whose monthly pension is 2,600 hryvnas ($90), 1,700 hryvnias ($60) for violating the crossing rules, Elenas lawyer said. The lawyer said that this has been a common practice since the restrictions were introduced and is particularly problematic for older people, who often live on small pensions and are not able to pay the fines. The fines can vary from 1,700 to 5100 hryvnias ($60-180).
The lawyer said that similar fines have been successfully appealed in Ukrainian courts:
This is basically a trap for people. The border guards threatened that if she doesnt pay the fine on the spot, they wont let her cross the border back, which they cant do, but people dont know that. They made her pay the fine. It is half of her pension, and the other half she spent on getting there in the first place.
Alena, DonetskAlena, is in her mid-30s and lives in Donetsk. Because she has permanent residence in Donetsk, she has been unable to travel to government-controlled territory since the pandemic-related restrictions were introduced. She is a single mother of a 2-year-old and looks after her 75-year-old mother-in-law, who has diabetes, and her older parents, who also have health issues. She said that the impact of the restrictions on her family has been devastating:
My mother in law cant get medicine and strips for her [diabetes] testing kit, which the Red Cross provides for her on the government side. I havent been getting child support for my son since February. My parents need medicine, they need their pensions. The only way to get all that is to travel for 30 hours through Russia, which is completely impossible in our circumstances.
When asked if she knew about humanitarian exemptions, Alena said that she thought the process was complicated and unclear:
They say you need to be pre-approved to travel. Ive seen people lining up to Pushilins [head of DNR] headquarters at all hours. Completely unclear how to get on these lists. They can say you are on the list and then you get to the checkpoint and turns out you are not on the list. I am not going to travel with a 2-year-old only to be turned around at the checkpoint.
Andrii, KupianskAndrii, 17, was refused entry to LNR to visit his grandmother who was ill. At the checkpoint, he presented his ID which showed Luhansk as his place of birth, but the men at the checkpoint held him for over an hour and then refused to let him through. They mocked his long hair, called him a Nazi, forced him to take off his shirt looking for tattoos, verbally abused him, and repeatedly threatened him with violence.
After Andrii walked back to the Ukraine government checkpoint he was required to self-isolate at his parents house for two weeks although he had not entered the nongovernment-controlled area.
Anastasiia, Donetska region Anastasiia lives in a government-controlled area of the Donetska region. In August, her mother, who lives in DNR, became ill after sustaining a fall and needed to be transported to government-controlled territory for treatment. Anastasia applied to the de facto authorities to transport her mother to a government-controlled city. Two weeks later, she was permitted to enter and underwent mandatory self-isolation for two weeks. Then she applied to leave DNR with her mother. The initial permission took five days but had to be amended because her mother needed to be transported by ambulance, which had to be added to the permission. The new permission was issued a month later, on October 29.
Nikolai, MakiivkaIn March, Nikolai left his home in Makiivka to get his pension and was stranded in government-controlled territory for several months after checkpoints were shut down. He returned to DNR in August and cannot leave again because he has no residence permit on the government-controlled side. To get his pension and address some work-related issues, he can now only travel through Russia, which costs him 3,500 hryvnas (approximately $120). His wife has a residence permit in a government-controlled city, but she can leave only if she signs a document declaring that she will not return until the Covid-19 situation improves, as required by DNR authorities.
Nikolais financial situation is dire, he said, and he sees no prospects in the future. I would like to sell my apartment here and move to the [government-controlled] side. But because of the conflict my apartment here is now worth a third of what it used to be, and I wont be able to buy anything with that money. All I can do now is pay money to ride back and forth through Russia in order to support myself.
Tamara, DebaltseveTamara lives with her 11-year old son and her 67-year-old mother. She said that before the pandemic, she regularly traveled to Kyiv for work, but had to stop traveling due to the restrictions. If I am not making money, we have nothing. I was getting child support [from DNR] and we had our vegetable garden to sustain us, thats it. On October 2, Tamara traveled to the government-controlled side through Russia. She said she didnt know how to get humanitarian exemptions but heard that people have to wait for a long time and are rejected frequently, so she didnt want to try. Tamara said she was not planning to return to Debaltseve until she made some money. She is currently working as a seamstress.
Impact of Closing the Stanytsia Luhanska Crossing Point on October 15 The Ukrainian government permits people to cross to government-controlled territory if they abide by 14-day self-isolation requirements. They are required to install the Act at Home app, which monitors quarantine compliance. There have been reports of the app malfunctioning, which can mean people were stuck at the line of contact or forced to quarantine at a medical facility for two weeks instead.
Human Rights Watch documented that the app and the self-isolation rules have prevented many older people who live in nongovernment-controlled territory from getting their pensions in government-controlled Ukraine because they could not afford to self-isolate on government-controlled territory or did not own a smartphone. There are no quarantine or self-isolation requirements in Ukraine for those crossing into Ukraine from Russia.
After the Stanytsia Luhanska crossing point was closed again on October 15, Ukrainian officials did allow some people to cross on humanitarian grounds, however Human Rights Watch also documented cases in which people were refused permission to cross, despite strong humanitarian circumstances. The apparently arbitrary decision-making causes unnecessary hardship. Ukrainian authorities should ensure that there is a clear and consistent process to apply for humanitarian exceptions that gives due weight to the impact the suspension has on their rights and prevents undue burdens for vulnerable people.
Nikolai, BelovodskNikolai, in his 60s, permanently lives in Belovodsk in LNR. He is the only guardian of his 9-year-old grandson, whose mother was killed in a car accident. On October 12, Nikolai traveled to Kyiv to attend a court hearing relating to the accident. When he returned to the crossing point on October 15, it was shut down. Ukrainian officials at the crossing point repeatedly rejected his requests to cross, he said, despite the fact that he had left his 9-year-old grandson at home and needed to get back to him. He also filed two official requests asking permission to cross from the Ukrainian authorities, but both were denied. He was stranded at the crossing point for 11 days before he was finally allowed to cross on October 25.
TatianaTatiana, who has a disability, was traveling to nongovernment-controlled territory after her son, who is blind, had eye surgery in Kyiv. She and her son arrived at the closed Stanytsia Luhanska crossing point on October 23. She said they were not allowed to cross and didnt have money for lodging so they had to spend the night at a distant relatives house several kilometers away. They were allowed to cross the next day, after humanitarian groups intervened on her behalf.
Go here to read the rest:
- Military becomes more tolerant of tattoos, obesity - The Korea Herald - December 3rd, 2020
- Mike Tyson Mao tattoo: what does it mean and why did he get it? - AS English - December 3rd, 2020
- David Fincher's Defiant Women in Gone Girl, Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - Collider.com - December 3rd, 2020
- This female tattoo artist from Afghanistan is breaking stereotypes with her creations - Times Now - December 3rd, 2020
- In Asia, 3 Jewelry Brands Reflect the Times - The New York Times - December 3rd, 2020
- When Professionalism Doesnt Look the Same to Everyone - Florence Health - December 3rd, 2020
- Keep Your Eye On These Young Designers From Around the World - W Magazine - December 3rd, 2020
- Worker woke to find word 'nonce' tattooed on forehead as two arrested for GBH - Mirror.co.uk - November 28th, 2020
- This Side of the Pond - Sundancetimes - November 28th, 2020
- The tattooist who breaks taboos and challenges conservative Afghan society - Inspired Traveler - November 27th, 2020
- Bev Callard's wild marriage to 'megash*g' husband Jon - tattoos and 22 bridesmaids - Mirror Online - November 27th, 2020
- Tatted Toy Guys turn hobby of collecting toys into Elizabethtown business - LancasterOnline - November 26th, 2020
- The Undertaker Tells Story Of Getting His First Tattoo And Naturally The Tale Involves The Hells Angels And The Ultimate Warrior - BroBible - November 26th, 2020
- Dot compensation: how thousands of tiny tattoos can help disguise the bald truth - Sydney Morning Herald - November 26th, 2020
- Western News - The Western News - November 26th, 2020
- Megan Fox Reveals New Tattoo At The AMAs. Here's What It Means - The List - November 23rd, 2020
- Police: Witness followed Windsor robbery suspects, leading to arrests - Journal Inquirer - November 23rd, 2020
- A Picture and its Story 2020: Part two - The Wider Image - November 23rd, 2020
- Born into occupation, young Afghans fear the Taliban will crush their freedoms when US troops exit - Anchorage Daily News - November 23rd, 2020
- Woman walked around with horror burns - Gympie Times - November 23rd, 2020
- Does AJ Pritchard have tattoos? What about the other Im A Celebrity stars? - Reality Titbit - Celebrity TV News - November 21st, 2020
- Born into occupation, young Afghans fear the Taliban will crush their freedoms when US troops exit - The Bakersfield Californian - November 21st, 2020
- Longer Looks: Interesting Reads You Might Have Missed - Kaiser Health News - November 21st, 2020
- Mysteries of Dolly Parton uncovered - secret tattoos and rarely-seen husband - Mirror Online - November 20th, 2020
- Tim Blanks' Top Fashion Shows of All-Time: Kim Jones Autumn/Winter 2005 - The Business of Fashion - November 20th, 2020
- Exhibition Review: Ink in the Lines, Australian War Memorial - ArtsHub - November 20th, 2020
- Craig Hlavaty: Why you should give the gift of blood for the holidays - Houston Chronicle - November 20th, 2020
- Police warning to dog owners after suspected attempted dog thefts - Cornwall Live - November 20th, 2020
- Scotland fan gets tattoo of famous Serbia result on upper thigh to celebrate reaching Euro 2020 - The Scottish Sun - November 20th, 2020
- The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Premiere Recap: Good Time Girls - Vulture - November 12th, 2020
- How about TAT! Women make up 70 percent of all tattoos in Poland - The First News - November 10th, 2020
- Heres What The Leaked Application For The Bachelor Looks Like - TheThings - November 10th, 2020
- These are the most wanted men by police in Norfolk in November 2020 - Eastern Daily Press - November 10th, 2020
- Check Out Nick Cannon's Muscular Body with Tattoos as He Shows It off during a Workout (Photo) - AmoMama - November 8th, 2020
- Have you seen them? They're accused of fatally shooting a man in the head - KHOU.com - November 8th, 2020
- These are the most wanted men by police in Norfolk in November 2020 - Thetford & Brandon Times - November 8th, 2020
- Part of a cultural encounter: Travel and its complicated history with tattooing - The Independent - November 8th, 2020
- And Now You Know: My story of meeting the Atakapas - Orange Leader - Orange Leader - November 8th, 2020
- Suns Deandre Ayton confuses the hell out of the internet with new tattoo - ClutchPoints - November 5th, 2020
- The Mystery Behind the Tattoos of Seth Rollins - EssentiallySports - November 5th, 2020
- Body modification addict gets pair of tusks - yes tusks - to go with tattooed eyeballs and split tongue - DubaiLAD - November 5th, 2020
- Tucson Salvage: A Clover in weeds, loss, homelessness, beatings and love - Tucson Weekly - November 5th, 2020
- Irezumi, the art of japanese Tattoo | Galerie &CO119 - Artsy - November 4th, 2020
- In an election season with new highs and lows, some campaign trick standouts - The Ledger - November 4th, 2020
- A Florida Demographic That Could Swing the Election - The New Yorker - November 3rd, 2020
- This Auburn cop killed 3 and injured others. His department didn't stop him outsiders did - KUOW News and Information - October 31st, 2020
- Dallas Man Arrested, Accused of Selling 19-Year-Old as Sex Slave to South Carolina Man - NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth - October 31st, 2020
- Lee Mack show The Chop cancelled after Nazi tattoos on contestants face could be connected to far-right id - The Sun - October 31st, 2020
- These arm tattoos will suit the arms, so you are thinking of getting an idea from here - Pledge Times - October 30th, 2020
- Growing tribe of Japanese proudly defies tattoo taboo, eyes Olympics boost - Yahoo! Voices - October 30th, 2020
- 'Taish' Is About Angry Young Men And Where Have We Seen That Before? - HuffPost India - October 30th, 2020
- Dallas man sold 19-year-old as sex slave to South Carolinian who wanted to brand her, feds allege - The Dallas Morning News - October 30th, 2020
- Help find 10 of South Yorkshire's most wanted men - Yorkshire Live - October 30th, 2020
- Getting Inked can impair sweating, make body to overheat - The Statesman - October 25th, 2020
- Deepdive: This is why #endsars trended this week - Mumbai Mirror - October 25th, 2020
- Male rappers are more than their music The Vermont Cynic - Vermont Cynic - October 24th, 2020
- Victor Ray Cruz Wanted to Turn His Life Around Then He Got the Coronavirus - Voice of San Diego - October 22nd, 2020
- Donations of blood wanted by hospital | News, Sports, Jobs - timesobserver.com - October 22nd, 2020
- The 40 Best Tattoo Ideas for Men Who Love Ink - menshealth.com - October 21st, 2020
- Women in Bhopal are getting tattoos of Goddess Durga to signify women empowerment - Free Press Journal - October 21st, 2020
- On Suits and Face Tattoos: The Black Community's Obsession with Respectability - The Southern Digest - October 21st, 2020
- Does Zac Efron Have Any Tattoos? The Answer Is Surprisingly Complicated - POPSUGAR - October 21st, 2020
- Dr. Dre and His Son Get Matching Tattoos - Rap-Up.com - October 21st, 2020
- I confronted my daughter's boyfriend but I was really confronting myself - The Guardian - October 19th, 2020
- 25 Carefree Bird Tattoos for Men in 2020 - The Trend Spotter - October 17th, 2020
- Three men with Canada wide warrants believed to be in Prince George area - My PG Now - October 17th, 2020
- Watch Brazen Burglars Steal Armloads of Laptops from Clovis Store. Police Seek Help to ID Them. - gvwire.com - October 17th, 2020
- Man believed to have Denham Springs ties wanted by Baton Rouge police for recent jewelry store theft - The Livingston Parish News - October 17th, 2020
- John Mayer's Royal Oak is the ultimate in low-key luxury - British GQ - October 17th, 2020
- TSR We Global: Members Of The ARISE News Crew Allege They Were Beaten By Authorities & Cameras Were Confiscated During An #EndSARS Protest... - October 14th, 2020
- Lifeblood say they can't bring in blood donation reforms earlier than 2021 - OUTinPerth - October 14th, 2020
- 10 of the best tattoos in the UFC (Photos) - FanSided - October 10th, 2020
- The art, meaning behind student tattoos | The Chimes - The Chimes - October 10th, 2020
- Proud Boys Rally Possibly Planned For Dolores Park (But Don't Assume These Jokers Are That Organized) - SFist - October 9th, 2020
- This Worcester beauty studio is on a mission to help breast cancer survivors move forward in recovery with a - MassLive.com - October 9th, 2020
- ACLU of Massachusetts will represent Bena Apreala, man stopped by unmarked officers while jogging in West Rox - MassLive.com - October 8th, 2020
- Boston leaders demand answers after Black man is stopped by ICE while jogging in West Roxbury - Boston.com - October 8th, 2020
- This former Rutgers star could have been shot by cops. Now he wants to become one. - NJ.com - October 8th, 2020
- Keeping His Eye on the Movement - INKED - October 8th, 2020
- ACLU Represents West Roxbury Man Stopped By ICE While Jogging - iHeartRadio - October 8th, 2020